Quick reference antiviral review chart


(maintained by Rob Slade)

This listing is intended to give a quick overview guide to the comparative features and effectiveness of the many different antiviral products. If the version numbers are out of date, please send updated copies for review to Rob Slade at the address given at the end of this list. The companion files Antiviral Software Evaluation FAQ (avrevfaq.html) and Antiviral contacts listing (CONTACTS.LST) provide additional related information. All three files are available in the Computer Virus SIG of the Victoria (BC, Canada) Freenet (telnet://guest@victoria.tc.ca and give the command "go virus"). (This file is the basis for Appendix B of "Robert Slade's Guide to Computer Viruses".)

This file is now maintained with minimal HTML formatting.


Product            Ver   Type    UI Doc Ease Ovrl Price Comments
                        SDRIMOE  CG 1-4  I U  1-4
                  |    |       |   |   |    |    |     |
Amiga

BootX (discontined)5.23  SDRM     G               free
amiga.physik.unizh.ch, ux1.cso.uiuc.edu 
or wuarchive.wustl.edu /mirrors2/amiga.physik.unizh.ch/util/virus
Reviewed

Computer Malware B.9508  info        4         4  Free
VTC, cert

LDV                1.73

VirusChecker       6.26                           free
amiga.physik.unizh.ch, ux1.cso.uiuc.edu or wuarchive.wustl.edu

VirusZ             3.06

Virus Tracker      2.45

ZeroVirus


Atari

Chasseur II              D
atari.archive.umich.edu 
Reviewed

FCHECK             25      I
atari.archive.umich.edu 
Reviewed

Protect6                 DR
atari.archive.umich.edu or larserio@ifi.uio.no
Reviewed

Sagrotan           4.12 S
atari.archive.umich.edu 
Reviewed


VIRUSDIE                S
atari.archive.umich.edu 
Reviewed


Computer Malware B.9508  info        4         4  Free
VTC, cert

VKILLER            3.84 SD
woodside@ttidca.com or atari.archive.umich.edu /atari/Utilities/Virus
Reviewed

Mac

Computer Malware B.9508  info        4         4  Free
VTC, cert

Disinfectant       3.7.1SDR                       Free
nwu, sumex-aim.stanford.edu, mac.archive.umich.edu

Gatekeeper       1.3      R MO                    Free  (no longer
supported)
Chris Johnson

Rival
Microseeds Publishing

SAM                5    SD  M                     $99
Symantec/Norton

Virex              4.5.5
(see MS-DOS, product not by same author)

VirusDetective     5.10.5
Jeff Shulman


MS-DOS

Advanced Security           MO   C   2   2 3   1
no longer supported
Reviewed

AntiViral ToolKit 3.0   SDRI                       $59.95
KAMI, various agents
Reviewed

Antivirus (IRIS)        SDR M    C   2   2 4   2   $49
Fink Enterprises
Reviewed

Antivirus-Plus          SDR M    C   2   2 4   2   $99
Trend Micro
Reviewed

AVAST!             7.7  SDRIMO   CG  3   3 2   3
ALWIL Software
Reviewed

Certus                  S RIMO   C   2   1 3   2
no longer supported, cf. Norton Antivirus
Reviewed

Computer Malware B.9508  info        4         4  Free  (note also
CARObase
VTC, cert                                                and CMB)

Central Point Anti-VirusSDRIMO    G  3   2 2   2
limited support, cf. Symantec/Norton, see also MSAV, Turbo AV
Reviewed

Control Room               I      G  2   4 4   2
no longer supported
Reviewed

Data Physician +  4.01  SDRIM    C   2   2 2   2
Digital Dispatch
Reviewed

Data Security Plus          MO   C   2   3 2   2
PC Guardian
Reviewed

DISKSECURE        2.42     IM    C   2   3 3   4        BSIs only
risc, urvax, eugene cf also FixMBR, FixUTIL
SafeMBR, CHKSMBR, CHKMEM, CHKBOOT in FixUtil etc. are free
Reviewed

Dr. Sol. AVToolkit 7.78 SDRIMO   CG  3   2 3   4
S&S International Ltd., support@sands.co.uk, support@us.drsolomon.com
Reviewed

Eliminator              SDR      C   3   2 3   2
(no longer supported)
Reviewed

F-PROT            2.28  SDR      CG  3   3 3   4 home - free, bus. -
$1/CPU
sales@complex.is, risc, urvax, eugene, garbo
Reviewed
Reviewed (Command Software)
Reviewed (Data Fellows)
Reviewed older version 1.xx with utilities

Freeze!!                    MO   C   2   3 3   2
Command Software
Reviewed

Hoffman Summary    702    info    G  3         3  $35
risc, urvax, eugene

HS                 3.58    I     C   2   2 2   3  $15
Stroem System Soft
Reviewed

HyperACCESS/5           S        C   2   1 2   2        term program
Higraeve                                                 with scanner
Reviewed

IBM Antivirus/DOS  3.0  SRDI     CG  2   2 2   3  $35
local IBM rep
Reviewed
Reviewed IBM scanner (no longer supported)

Immune II          4.1  SD  M    CG  1   1 3   2  $40
Higher Ground Diagnositcs                               (see also PC-
Cillin)
Reviewed

Immunizer                   MO   C   1   1 1   1
Western Digital
Reviewed

Integrity Master   3.21 S  I     CG  4   3 3   3  $28
risc, urvax, eugene
Reviewed

InocuLAN                S   MO   C   2   2 2   2
Cheyenne Software
Reviewed

Mace Vaccine                MO   C   1   3 2   2
no longer supported
Reviewed

Network Security Organizer       CG  2   3 3   2
Thompson Network Software (cf. OnTrack?)
Reviewed

Norton AntiVirus   3.0  SDRI      G  2   3 2   3  $130
Symantec, see also Central Point
Reviewed

PC-Cillin         5.02  SDRIM    C   3   3 3   2  $139
Trend Micro (no longer supported?) cf. Immune II
Reviewed

PC/DACS                     MOE  CG  3   2 2   2
Mergent
Reviewed

PC-Vault                     O   C   2   3 3   1
Johnson Computer Systems
Reviewed

Rising Anti-Virus           M    C   1   2 2   2
Rising Science and Technology Inc.
Reviewed

SAFE                       IMOE  C   1   2 1   2
Micronyx
Reviewed

SafeWord Virus-Safe1.12    I     C   2   3 4   3
Enigma Logic
Reviewed

Security Guardian           MOE  C   2   2 3   3
Command Software
Reviewed

SIX (also BRECT)   3.08    I     C   2   3 2   2  Free
DriftNet BBS +1-506-325-9002
Reviewed

Thunderbyte Utility8.04 SDRIMOE  C   2   2 3   3  $29
risc, urvax, eugene, garbo
Reviewed
Reviewed Professional version
Reviewed (older scan only version)

Untouchable        1.1  SDRIM    CG  2   2 2   2        PCUNTUCH.RVW
no longer supported, see also V-Analyst/B.R.M.
Reviewed

VACCINE (WWS)      5.00 SD IMO   C   2   1 2   2
The Davidsohn Group
Reviewed

VACCINE (Sophos)   9111 S  I     CG  2   2 2   3
Sophos
Reviewed

VDS                2.10T   I     CG  2   2 3   2
risc, urvax, eugene
Reviewed

VET                9.0  SDRIM    CG  3   3 3   3
Cybec
Reviewed

Victor Charlie     5.0     IM    C   3   2 3   3  $99
(limited support?)
Reviewed

VirAway                 S        C   1   3 2  2   $49
Techmar Computer Products, cf. Antivirus-Plus, Inoculan
Reviewed

Virex-PC           2.99 SDRIM     G  4   2 4   4   $49
Datawatch, limited support
Reviewed

ViruCide                SD       CG  3     4   3
Parsons, cf. McAfee (no longer supported), Trend, Cheyenne
Reviewed

Virus0Buster       4.84 SDRIMO   CG  3   3 3   4
Leprechaun Software
Reviewed

VIRUSCAN Suite     3.1.4SDRIM    C   2   2 2   3  ~$25/module
risc, urvax, SIMTEL, garbo, mcafee.com
Reviewed

VirusNet PC             SDRI     CG  3   3 3   3
SafetyNet, cf. F-PROT
Reviewed

VirusProtect       4.0  S        CG  1   2 2   2
Intel
Reviewed

VirusSafe LAN      7.1  SDRI O   CG  2   2 3   2
EliaShim Micro
Reviewed

Vi-Spy             14.0 SDR M    CG  2   2 3   3  $150
RG Software Systems
Reviewed

Watchdog            7       MOE  C   3   3 3   3
Fischer International
Reviewed

Watchdog Armor Card         MOE  C   3   2 3   3
Fischer International
Reviewed


OS/2

HyperACCESS/5           S        C   2   1 2   2        term program
Higraeve                                                 with scanner
Reviewed

IBM Antivirus/OS/2 2.5  SRDI     CG  2   2 2   3  $35
local IBM rep
Reviewed

SCAN/OS/2 Suite    2.22 SDRIM    C   2   2 2   3  ~$35/module
risc, urvax, SIMTEL, garbo, mcafee.com


UNIX

Computer Malware B.9508  info        4         4  Free
VTC, cert

Tripwire                   I                      Free
ftp.cs.purdue.edu pub/spaf/COAST/Tripwire

VirusScan/Solaris       SD                        U$200/server
risc, urvax, SIMTEL, garbo, mcafee.com

                  |    |       |   |   |    |    |     |

Key:

Type - S=scanner, D=disinfection (restoration of state), R=resident,
          I=integrity checking, M=activity monitor, O=operation
restricting,
          E=encryption

UI - user interface - C=command line, G=menu or GUI

The following are based on a 1=poor - 4=excellent scale
Doc - documentation
Ease - I=installation, U=use
Ovrl - overall rating for general use

Sites:

VTC - ftp.informatik.uni-hamburg.de (134.100.4.42)
cert - virus materials now moved to cs.ucr.edu
eugene - eugene.utmb.edu (129.109.9.21)
garbo - garbo.uwasa.fi (193.166.120.5)
nwu - ftp.acns.nwu.edu (129.105.113.52)
risc - risc.ua.edu (130.160.4.7)
simtel - ftp.coast.net (mirrored at other places)
urvax - urvax.urich.edu (141.166.36.6)

For more detailed reviews see /pub/virus-l/docs/reviews at cert or
http://www.victoria.tc.ca/techrev/quickref.html

For general virus info see the VIRUS-L/comp.virus FAQ at
ftp://ftp.infospace.com/pub/virus-l (IP address 206.129.166.107)

Shipping Address
Please send updated versions of antivirals to Rob Slade at 3118 Baird
Road, North Vancouver, BC, Canada, V7K 2G6.  Publishers shipping from
outside of Canada are advised to label the materials as samples per
GST section 215(1), without value and not subject to GST.  Please note
that UPS and RPS seem to have extreme difficulty in getting shipments
into the country.  (In addition, I am in support of the proposed
boycott of UPS over their sale of digitized signatures.)  Neither Rob
Slade nor V.I.R.U.S. take any responsibility for shipments delayed or
refused at Customs for failure to follow these directions.

copyright Robert M. Slade, 1992-97   QUICKREF.RVW   980205

HyperText version Book Review Index (may take a while to load)

Book reviews main topic menu

Virus information main menu